US-Canada trade war rattles Asian markets | The World

Tensions between the United States and Canada are deepening after crucial trade talks collapsed last month. While President Trump is doubling down on steeper tariffs, Canada continues to take a hardline approach despite the risk of severe economic consequences. Well, for more on this, we’re joined by Steven Naggie, a professor of politics and international studies at the International Christian University of Tokyo.

Steven, good to have you on our program tonight. Now tell us how troubling is this trade spat between the US and Canada? I’m interested to find out what your views are as a Canadian expat.  Yeah, you know what? I look at this and I think it’s a completely unnecessary uh spat again between two neighbors that have a geographic proximity, institutional proximity, linguistic, cultural and and frankly historical proximity.

Um, like Australia, uh, Canada has been side by side with the United States in some of its greatest, uh, challenges, including 9/11, where we welcomed literally tens of thousands of families into Canadian homes after, uh, the United States was attacked by al-Qaeda. So, this is bewildering and and I think many Canadians just wonder where this came from.

Which industries will take the greatest hit and which side do you think will be the biggest loser in this trade war as it stands right now? Well, the United States is about 10 times bigger than Canada in terms of its its its its economy. Uh, and the complexity of the economy of course gives it global reach in the way that the Canadian economy uh doesn’t.

The Canadian economy like the Australian economy is based on resources, agricultural uh some service sector. Uh but it really means that uh Canada is going to suffer much more from this uh trade uh war. Um which industries? We think the automobile industry, dairy, um, of course, tourism will all face uh, real challenges as this trade dispute does continue.

Uh, and I think many Canadians are wondering, you know, what can actually be done to solve this problem immediately? Uh, how long can families and businesses manage the pressure from the United States? And what is the direction moving forward after a trade dispute that’s become quite bitter? But yet many uh of the Canadians back home uh largely agree with the move that Mark Carney has made.

 I think this is um politically popular and and to be frank I think um the current leader of the United States has made it quite um uh easy I think for for Prime Minister Carney to gather Canadians and to rally behind uh Prime Minister Carney’s position visav the trade spat. But again, most of the uh comments coming out of Washington, whether it’s the 51st state comment, whether it’s about Lake America versus Lake Ontario really um he’s I think he’s offended Canadians in ways that u was really unthinkable even 5 years ago. Um

the question though is what is in Canada’s national interest? And I I do believe that Canada’s national interests really are um we we cannot escape the the economic gravity of North America, of the United States. We share a 6,000 kilometer border, similar institutions, language, and culture which make it very difficult to diversify away from the United States.

And in that sense, Prime Minister Carney’s real job is to um pull Canadians away from this anti-Trump and anti- American um I guess uh stance and try to find a way to move forward and rebuild the relationship. Stephen, I wanted to ask you, how closely are Asian trading partners watching this trade spat between the US and Canada because this will impact them quite a fair bit.

 Absolutely. You know, uh, Canada’s comparative advantage, of course, it has energy, it has agriculture, it has great services, but ultimately its comparative advantage is its access to the United States. So whether it’s Japan or South Korea, Southeast Asian countries or even Australia, New Zealand, um when they look at the North American market, they’re entering in some cases through the Canadian border as part of their broader economic strategy.

So they’re worried. They’re worried that if relations continue to um bifurcate and become more problematic, what do they do about their investments in Canada and in North America in general? And I think all the capitals are hoping that the Canadians and the Americans come to a quick settlement and they return to business as normal.

Leave a Comment